1

Obama Asks Congress to Authorize Another Endless War

Sarah Lazare | Commondreams

"Obama has to decide on his legacy," said Phyllis Bennis. "Does he want the legacy that he was the president to end wars, or does he want to be present to make wars endless?" (Photo: White House/flickr/public domain)

“Obama has to decide on his legacy,” said Phyllis Bennis. “Does he want the legacy that he was the president to end wars, or does he want to be present to make wars endless?” (Photo: White House/flickr/public domain)

President Barack Obama on Wednesday formally asked Congress for expansive authorization of the U.S.-led war on ISIS, including a green-light for open-ended and geographically limitless military operations.

While lawmakers in Washington discuss details of the proposed authorization for use of military force (AUMF), analysts point out that meaningful debate about the war itself has been left completely off the table.

“This shows that Congress is not even debating the issue of force,” Phyllis Bennis, senior fellow at Institute for Policy Studies, told Common Dreams. “They are simply debating some small questions of limits or not limits.”

Raed Jarrar, expert on Middle East politics and Policy Impact Coordinator for the American Friends Service Committee, told Common Dreams that the text of Obama’s proposed AUMF is a “worst case scenario” because it “doesn’t place any limitations on war.”

“The bottom line is, you cannot bomb extremism out of existence.” 
—Phyllis Bennis, Institute for Policy Studies
Contents of the President’s Proposal

Obama submitted the AUMF despite his controversialclaim that he does not, legally, need to put use of military force to a vote.

The key details of the request were shared with Senate Democrats on Tuesday, and the full text was formally submitted on Wednesday. The proposal calls for:

  • Authorization of three more years of military force, extending the war to the next administration, which could then seek reauthorization.
  • Permission to deploy troops, with the exception of “enduring offensive ground combat operations.” Analysts have pointed out that this vaguely-worded prohibition would likely open the door to significant boots on the ground. “The limits on ground troops are as vague as they were in 2001,” said Bennis. “Ground troops are ground troops. Once they are on the ground, you don’t always get to chose whether they fight or not.”
  • War against “individuals and organizations fighting for, on behalf of, or alongside [ISIS] or any closely-related successor entity in hostilities against the United States or its coalition partners.” Similar to the 2001 AUMF, this defines the “enemy” in extremely broad terms.
  • No geographical limitations.
  • Repeal of the 2002 AUMF, which authorized the 2003 invasion of Iraq and use of force against Saddam Hussein, but no repeal of the controversial 2001 AUMF, which was passed in the wake of September 11th, 2001 and has been used to justify wars and troops deployments from Afghanistan to Somalia to Ethopia.

Several key details are omitted from the proposal. They include:

  • Clear definition of military objective and what “winning” looks like.
  • Discussion of the U.S.-led air war, which, in the past six months, has launched at least 2,361 bombings in Iraq and Syria.
  • Commitment to transparency regarding civilian deaths, nature of U.S. warfare, and military branches conducting operations.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry released a statement publicly praising the AUMF proposal as “important for our country” and urged Congress to work together on its passage.

“This is truly an authorization for another endless war.”
—Raed Jarrar, American Friends Service Committee
Representative Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) released astatement on Wednesday in which he applauded the president for the proposal but objected to the lack of limitations. Schiff urged a sunset for the 2001 AUMF (which the president has previously criticized) and expressed concerns over the lack of “geographic limitation and a broad definition of associated forces.”

Meanwhile, Representative John Boehner (R-Ohio), the Speaker of the House, toldreporters after a meeting with Republican representatives, “I’m not sure the strategy that has been outlined will accomplish the mission the president says he wants to accomplish.”

Objection to Endless War

Outside of the White House and Capitol Hill, grassroots organizations, legal experts, and regional analysts expressed deep concerns about the request, including objections to its specific contents and omissions, as well as overall opposition to the war itself.

Jarrar pointed out, “There are no geographic limitations or target limitations, and this even allows for ground troops to be involved in the war. This proposal doesn’t talk about the fact that the U.S. has been arming and equipping proxy groups accused of gross human rights violations and acts, as if these proxy groups don’t exist. This is truly an authorization for another endless war.”

Chris Anders, senior legislative counsel with the American Civil Liberties Union, added in statement released Wednesday that the proposal “fails to make clear that the new enactment will be the exclusive authority for the use of military force against ISIS, which leaves open the possibility that the executive branch will continue to rely inappropriately on the authorization that Congress passed in 2001.”

Furthermore, Anders noted that the lack of geographical limitations means that “the executive branch may interpret it to authorize the use of force far from the battlefield in Iraq.”

The Win Without War Coalition released a statement which urges Congress “to reject the pursuit of a military solution to a conflict that does not have one.”

“American bombs have been falling on the Middle East for decades and they have only served to destabilize the region and prolong conflicts,” the statement continues. “[T]he idea that more of the same is going to produce a different result is the definition of insanity.”

According to Bennis, “The bottom line is, you cannot bomb extremism out of existence. You can bomb people and kill them. Obama has to decide on his legacy. Does he want the legacy that he was the president to end wars, or does he want to be the president who makes wars endless?”

More from Commondreams




Popular Resistance: The People Are Ready for Action

PopularResistance.org

There is no doubt that the people are rising. Today there are at least three major events taking place – the Ferguson October massive march to end police brutality and racism in St. Louis, the European-wide day of actions against the Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Agreement (TAFTA) and the Global Frackdown. People are also protesting the World Bank meeting in Washington, DC and the Maine Walk for Peace is beginning.

DemilitarizePolice

This week we remembered Popular Resistance’s roots in the occupation of Freedom Plaza which began as October 2011. At that time we wondered if people were ready to take stronger actions to challenge the corrupt political and economic systems that rule and the answer in the form of hundreds of occupations and the ongoing protests that followed was a clear ‘Yes!”

That momentum continues to build through meetings, networking, actions and the creation of new systems. The culture of the movement now is ‘convergence’ and the question is: “How do we work together more effectively to change the system?” Even traditional non-governmental organizations are starting to question whether they are challenging the system or perpetuating it. This is good news. The tide is shifting.

Thousands march for justice in St. Louis

Grassroots groups in Ferguson, MO called for people to join them for a weekend of nonviolent action and thousands responded. The weekend began with a march from Clayton to the police station last night and today thousands marched in downtown St. Louis. The marches are well-organized and peaceful. The future may not be so peaceful as police are coordinating with the FBI to prepare for possible riots if the grand jury does not indict Officer Darren Wilson.

Getting justice for Mike Brown and the hundreds of others who are killed by police each year is an uphill battle. Davey D wrote about his concerns around another murder by police of an 18 year old black teen in St. Louis this past week, Vonderrick Myers. While doubts were raised about the actions of an unidentified off-duty police officer, police immediately pointed to Myers’ arrest record. But in an area that overwhelmingly arrests black males, it’s hard to escape having a record.

The roots of racism and police violence are long and deep in the United States. These issues have been bubbling at the surface for a while. Mike Brown’s murder and the clear injustices in Ferguson brought them to a boil. Now the question is how to use this energy and attention to solve these crises rather than adding to them. Here is one vision that has been put forth which suggests expanding the work beyond civil rights to a human rights framework.

The Ohio Student’s Association organized and carried out a powerful campaign this week seeking justice for John Crawford, 21 years old, who was murdered by an officer in a Walmart while carrying a toy gun. The students started by occupying the police station for 3 days asking for a meeting with the chief and when the chief did not accept their basic demands, they shut down the office by sitting-in outside of it.

We need more campaigns like this. And we need more actions like this lawyer took who saw a black man being stopped by police for no reason other than walking in a wealthy neighborhood. She confronted the police and told them to get out of the neighborhood. We need to understand our legal rights and help each other. Check out the Civil Liberties Defense Center for helpful resources. And remember that this is Domestic Violence Awareness Month. The Free Marissa campaign is calling on Florida to drop the charges against Marissa Alexander.

Stopping Neoliberalism

The economic system that we are working to change is a form of capitalism called neo-liberalism. It’s a system that puts profit ahead of human rights and protection of the planet. It turns everything into a commodity. It privatizes our Commons and services through ‘public-private partnerships’ which are less partnership and more plundering.

The World Bank is a prime culprit in the global neo-liberal agenda and it’s time to call them out for it. Here is a new report that dispels the myths around the World Bank’s new approach to agriculture which is displacing millions of Indigenous People from their land. Another report shows that the World Bank is failing to address energy poverty. The World Bank annual meeting is in Washington, DC this weekend. Lively protests were held there yesterday featuring Reverend Billy and the Stop Shopping Choir and today. It was organized by the Our Land Our Business campaign and was part of an international day of action.

Other tools for the neoliberal agenda are global trade agreements such as the TPP and TAFTA.  They give legal rights for corporations to sue governments if laws interfere with profits. Lambert Strether wrote about some of the worst ways this power has been abused. And this article describes a similar case in New Brunswick that threatens to open the area to fracking.

Today there were actions throughout Europe to protest the Atlantic agreement, TAFTA. And we are preparing for a week of actions to stop the TPP and TAFTA in November. Last year there were 35 actions in the US on the national day of action to stop the TPP. We can double that this year and send a strong message to Congress. Click here to learn more about what you can do.

Fossil Fuel Industry Forges Ahead

We must continue to escalate actions to stop the fossil fuel industry. This week, a gas pipeline that is heavily opposed by the public was approved in Vermont. A massive sit-in is being organized in Montpelier for October 27 to protest it. Join them if you can! Click here for more information.

PeterShumlin

The Federal Energy Regulation Commission recently approved the storage of methane gas in a cavern at Lake Seneca in New York and the construction of a gas export terminal in Maryland. Both of these are heavily opposed and the environmental impacts were inadequately studied. And it was revealed this week that the Cuomo administration pressured the USGS to alter a key study on the impacts of fracking.

That’s why the week of actions in Washington, DC from November 1 to 8, called Beyond Extreme Energy, couldn’t come at a better time. The FERC will be one of many targets. You can learn more and sign up here. We urge you to join the new Popular Resistance Climate Justice affinity group. We are organizing an action in DC on November 3 as part of Beyond Extreme Energy which you can join and if you can’t, we’ll keep you informed of activities around climate justice. Click here to sign up.

Stopping the War Machine

This week marked the beginning of the 14th year in Afghanistan. We marked that anniversary with a ceremony at the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in New York City. For those of you who have followed the annual ceremony there, you will be pleased to know that the curfew was lifted and there were no arrests. This victory was bittersweet as we mourned the expansion of war and the continuing epidemic of suicides by veterans.

Once more, the Masters of War have succeeded in convincing the public to accept more wars. Jason Hirthler explains why the US is entering another quagmire. Unfortunately, endless war is the doctrine of the United States and it is embraced by both dominant political parties. Scott Tucker warns that peace activists must take on the Democratic Party if there is to be an end to war. As we did last fall, David Swanson calls for the anti-war movement to move past partisanship and work together to stop war.

ColumbusNotHero
And we urge you to take time this weekend to learn more about America’s first war, also called the American Holocaust.  Elysse Bruce of Idle No More explains why Columbus should not be celebrated and in fact, Seattle just voted to celebrate Indigenous Peoples this Monday.

There is a lot happening and a lot to do. To learn more about the constructive actions that people are taking to create a better world, we urge you to visit the Create page on Popular Resistance. And if you are engaged in constructive work in your community, please share that with us by emailinginfo@popularresistance.org.